We were not blessed with the acumen to parse and filter the law.
Bu there is something particularly curious about headlines that boast of Government’s plans to harness speech deemed offensive on Social Media platforms.
There’s any number of incidents that would pass the ‘offensive’ test.
We recall, during the public show of anguish after the tragedy of 11 year old Adriana Younge, the distasteful and racially charged commentary posted on Face Book, by some.
Earlier that year, a Leader in APNU was threatened with the use of the Ethnic Relations Committee for using a specific reference with racial overtones.
This post by Tribanie Singh, with its sexually perverted allusion in the midst of what had devolved into a racially divisive case, was never referred for any kind of sanction by any oversight body …that can be researched.
And we say this to underscore how these complaints can be perceived by those who choose to air a grievance, pursuant to their rights.
We’ve noted this categorization of opinions by the office that’s initiating the oversight of social media speech and wonder at inherent bias, in terms like ‘impish’.
For the record, we categorically denounce opinions that devolve into profanity and the taunting and name calling that have become the signature of many.
Registering protest is a civic duty and responsibility and comes with the airs that go with that. Civility is a core standard of protest. Civic duty with grace preserves the decorum that goes with the privilege.
And the baiting that’s standard fare on Social Media is prone to have retaliatory consequences that remove the platform.
Forget about citing historic protest leaders. This does not need that. This needs responsible and effective expression anchored in the realities of the daily lived experience.
And the adhoc pockets of sentiment that run counter to their own cause, is testament to the text book examples of ‘Protest without a Plan’. It’s this discordance with aim, purpose, result and path forward, that Governments tend to use to gauge how to craft their path ahead.
We’re in the modern era. Government decision to control conversation is as new as as the media format itself. But Government attempts to reach into conversations are as old as Government.
We’re no opponents to free speech, lest we are labeled amongst those who oppose all regulation of social media discourse.
Our thinking is that there’s a threshold in public opinion where debate ceases to be an academic exercise and becomes a moral imperative. There’s a difference between incitement and enticement. Social media platforms used for either should be policed.
Why?
These acts cross that decency/safety threshold in public discourse that activate governing common sense. Plotting against the government or any of its operatives on Social Media is not only fundamental stupidity but performative attention seeking.
Using social media to appeal to a specific group through their racial vulnerabilities or propensities for deviant social activities is preying upon weakness to engage in activities that may be lawbreaking. The platform has the responsibility to note and advise against ill intent.
In this respect, we agree with policing.
There is a tendency by Government(s), however, to overstep its own boundaries and cherry pick what is more egregious than some.
And this brings us to the Ethnic Relations Committee, ERC.
We remember the provocative commentary by this, Jennifer Ally, over the course of civil unrest after the death of Adriana Younge. Much ado was made about Ally’s remedial education with the ERC, her racial sensitivity training and her ensuing penitence.
We just happened capture a collage of her post -rectification sentiment, amongst which is her boast of being a proud PPP Party hooligan, as she taunts Black people after her ERC racial desensitizing.
And this one, in particular, underscores where oversight becomes a performative ritual. She was so cleansed from her reference to black male tropes that she couldn’t resist this jab at black men working– let alone saving money, after she attended ERC school.
We’d say that her access to accurate economic data on black male unemployment and marginalization, in an environment that labels citizens whose welfare they are responsible for ‘Hungry Bellies’, may be her reference.
But that’s for another topic.
The point here is that this self-confessed PPP hooligan , who went through an ERC catharsis a few months before her gratuitous racial post
and passed the Ethnic Relations test with such honors, was allowed to resume her contribution to One Guyana, via the same social media platform she had abused.
Not to fault the ERC though, gauging its firm commitment to the process. Her relapse points were noted in media with due admonition
… a pledge to closely monitor her public disrespect for Afro Guyanese and to call her in again if she broke the ERC rules …AGAIN.
And now that government is venturing into deeper oversight, having hired a dedicated Attorney for the effort….Ms Ally’s ERC adventurism regurgitates as evidence on how some offenders are treated, as well as the basis of any selectivity.
It seems, per President Ali’s quote in this article , that his hiring of this specific attorney, with this distinct skill set, is to combat misinformation, disinformation and lies against him and other senior officials. He deemed it character assassination which everyone, we agree, has the right to defend against.
Everyone, though, is not a politician in society with the power to activate the levers of government for personal protection.
We are not going to look back at Article 9 , for example, which tells lay people like us that the power belongs to them and is exercised for them by their elected officials. Voters know that and know that politicians know they are empowered to serve the people.
Politicians are part of the people, so they serve themselves but on the basis of the built in honor that courses through the Articles on what contracts Government and Governance.
When the President, with the inherent power of office, addresses his personal grievance we have to juxtapose this advantage against others.
The victims of verbal malice, steeped in racial identity, suggest equal damage. We say this because the conduct was admonished by the Ethnic Relations Committee. Their characters, too, were/are assassinated by a consistent barrage of ethnic degradation.
The question now is if the lawyer, cited by the President as possessing the skill set to quell character assassinations, will be unleashed selectively. The characters of all Guyanese who fall victim to poison pens deserve the full weight of public defense and the restoration of their good names.
And like the President’s, their characters, too, were assassinated and deserve public restoration. Death is death.If we’re in the business of resurrection of public office, which implies public funding, the corpses cannot be selected based on public hierarchy but on manner of death – character assassination.
We’re not lawyers but somewhere in here is, at least, one offense committed against Black People . And these social media posts of the graduate of ERC remediation confess that she’s unbothered by an ERC rebuke.
The question now is if the lawyer cited by the President as possessing the skill set to quell character assassinations will be unleashed with retroactive authority.
When a government decides to go after a criminal act and appoint authorities to do so, it does not exclude acts committed before the appointment.
And it’s not like face book is not a repository of the crimes and criminals the Attorney would have to go after. If the aim is restore assassinated characters, Facebook has a hit list of these assassins and their repeat offenses and the victims.
We have seen the pictorial slaughter of Government Ministers, claims of apartheid by foot soldiers of a specific Party, and the vitriol
they traffic via Face Book. We’ve seen their race baiting in this fake photo of Haitians arriving to vote in Guyana. We traced the
google address to a stock photo from Alazeera, of Africans fleeing their homes taken over by rebels to neighboring States offering asylum.
We found a few of the names of the character assassins the President’s new Counsel should be interested in.
And while this person is a gleeful concocter of a great portion of hate, he is just one soldier in the army of character assassins the President’s Counsel may find interesting, given his new portfolio and the President’s new mission.
Of course, there are several more identity markers littered on Face Book by these assassins. This one shows how it trickles past the target to family members. It’s an occupational hazard of not being aligned with their Party of choice.
Again, we say we agree with Government’s decision to police commentary on Social Media, but only to the extent that it is done
within the confines of written law and or policy and not simply at the discretion of the Special Counsel.
This is actually a concern. There are copious examples of bias associated with this type of appointment.
They range from prosecution to justify the appointed position, to a slanted approach to curry favor with the government, through partiality and prejudice in decision making.
We’re sure the aim of this policing of Social Media is not for it to look like a shield for the powerful instead of a safeguard for the public.
Either the law protects every citizen’s good name from character assassination—on every timeline and across every political divide—or it is merely policing the boundaries of privilege for revenge.
****Hey Readers:
Hit reply to share your thoughts—We read every response ****

